Boots or Trail Runners: Choosing Hiking Footwear

Twenty years ago the answer was simple: you hiked in boots, and the heavier the better. Then long-distance walkers started finishing 4,000 km trails in shoes that looked like they belonged on a running track, and the argument has not stopped since. We have worn both for thousands of kilometres, and we have come to think the question is not which is better, but which is better for this trip, this load and these feet. Here is how we decide, and the evidence behind it.

Weight on the feet, weight on the back

The oldest argument for lighter footwear is also the strongest. Military research going back decades found that carrying weight on the feet costs roughly four to six times as much energy as carrying the same weight on the back, because every gram on the foot has to be accelerated and lifted with each stride. The commonly quoted rule of thumb, that one pound on your feet equals about five pounds in your pack, comes from that work. A pair of full-leather boots can weigh 1.5 kg (3.3 lb), while a pair of trail runners weighs around 600 g (1.3 lb). Over a day of 25,000 steps, the difference is real: measurably less fatigue, a slightly faster natural pace, and less strain on hips and knees. It is the main reason long-distance hikers switched, and the numbers have not changed since.

The ankle support question

The usual reason people give for boots is ankle support, and the evidence for it is weaker than most of us assume. Studies of hikers and of soldiers have not shown that high-cut boots reduce the rate of ankle sprains in any consistent way. A boot collar made of soft leather or fabric provides very little resistance to the sideways roll that causes a sprain; what it does is limit the range of motion slightly and give a sense of security. What actually prevents sprains is strength, balance and practice on uneven ground, and there is a reasonable argument that low shoes develop those things precisely because the ankle has to do its own work.

That said, boots do protect. A stiff, high collar shields the ankle bones from rock strikes on talus, keeps scree and mud out, and resists twisting when you are carrying a heavy load that raises your centre of gravity. If you have a history of serious sprains or an ankle that is unstable, a supportive boot combined with strengthening exercises is a sensible choice. For most hikers on maintained trails with a moderate pack, the ankle argument alone is not a reason to carry the extra weight.

Waterproof membranes versus drainage

This is where the two philosophies really diverge. A boot with a waterproof breathable membrane keeps water out until it comes over the top, and then it keeps the water in, because the same membrane that stops rain also stops the boot draining. A wet membrane boot can take two days to dry. A mesh trail runner without a membrane soaks through in the first puddle and drains and dries in an hour of walking. Membranes also reduce breathability, which means sweatier feet in warm weather and more blisters.

The choice comes down to conditions. In cold, snowy or persistently wet-and-cold climates, where wet feet mean cold feet and cold feet mean risk, a waterproof boot with a wool sock is the right tool. In warm climates, in summer mountains, in the desert and on long trips where you will cross streams every day, shoes that drain win easily. Our compromise on long walks is non-waterproof shoes with a light gaiter to keep debris out, and a dry pair of socks reserved for camp.

Sizing for feet that swell

Feet swell over a long day and even more over a multi-day trip, and a shoe that felt right in the shop on a cool morning can be crushing your toes by the afternoon of day three. Whichever style you choose, try footwear on late in the day, with the socks you will hike in, and look for a full thumb width of space in front of the longest toe. Many experienced walkers go up half a size, and some a full size, from their street shoes. Then test on a downhill: if your toes hit the front, the shoe is too short or the lacing too loose, and you will lose toenails on the first long descent. Width matters as much as length; a foot that is squeezed sideways will blister no matter how good the sock.

Lugs, break-in and lifespan

Look at the sole. Lug depth of around 4 to 6 mm suits most trails; deeper, widely spaced lugs shed mud in wet forests, while shallower, closer lugs with a stickier rubber compound grip better on dry rock and slabs. Trail runners generally use softer rubber that grips well but wears faster. Boots use harder compounds that last longer and hold up under a heavy load.

Break-in is a genuine difference. A leather boot needs somewhere between 30 and 50 km (20 to 30 miles) of walking before it moulds to your foot, and taking a new pair straight onto a long trip is a classic way to ruin it. Modern trail runners need almost none; you can wear them out of the box. The trade-off is durability. Expect 500 to 800 km (300 to 500 miles) from a pair of trail runners before the cushioning and outsole are done, against well over 1,000 km (600 miles), and sometimes several times that with a resole, from a good leather boot.

When boots still win

None of this makes boots obsolete. There are situations where we reach for them without hesitation:

  • Heavy loads, roughly 18 kg (40 lb) and up, where a stiff sole and high collar stop the foot rolling under the weight
  • Snow, ice and any route that needs crampons or microspikes, which require a rigid sole and a warm, waterproof upper
  • Sustained off-trail travel on talus, scree and boulder fields, where the protection from rock strikes matters more than weight
  • Cold, wet climates where feet must stay dry to stay warm
  • Ankles with a history of serious injury, in combination with proper strengthening

For everything else, which for most of us is most hiking, a well-fitted pair of trail shoes is lighter, cooler, dries faster and is kinder to the legs over a long day. The best footwear is the pair that fits, suits the ground you will walk on, and lets you forget about your feet entirely.