Water is the heaviest thing in any pack, at a full kilogram per litre, and it is also the one thing we cannot skip. Carry too little and the afternoon turns into a headache and a stumble. Carry too much and the knees pay for it on every descent. Then there is the question of what is actually in that clear mountain stream, and what to do about it before drinking. We have used most of the treatment methods over the years, and each has a place. This is how we decide what to carry, how to treat it, and how much to have on us.
What lives in the water
Backcountry water carries three kinds of problems, and they are very different in size. Protozoa such as Giardia and Cryptosporidium are the big ones, at 1 to 15 microns across. They come from animal and human waste, they are common in North American streams below grazing land or busy campsites, and a Giardia infection takes one to three weeks to show up as cramps and diarrhoea that last for weeks more. Bacteria such as E. coli and Salmonella are smaller, around 0.2 to 5 microns, and cause faster, shorter illness. Viruses such as norovirus and hepatitis A are tiny, at 0.02 to 0.1 microns, and in North American wilderness they are rare, because they spread mostly person to person and do not survive long in cold water. In developing countries and in water downstream of villages, viruses are the main concern.
In most of the United States, Canada and Western Europe, then, you are treating for protozoa and bacteria. That is what a filter does. Anywhere you suspect human sewage, you need chemicals, UV or boiling on top.
Hollow-fibre filters and the freezing problem
The hollow-fibre filter is the tool most of us carry now. It is a bundle of thin tubes with pores of about 0.1 to 0.2 microns, which blocks protozoa and bacteria completely but lets viruses through. The squeeze versions weigh 60 to 90 grams, produce about a litre a minute when clean, and are rated for tens of thousands of litres. Gravity versions using a 3 or 4 litre dirty bag are the comfortable choice for groups, filtering 1.5 litres a minute while you set up the tent.
Two things kill them. The first is silt, which clogs the fibres and drops the flow to a dribble. Backflush after every trip and let cloudy water settle in a bag for 20 minutes before filtering, and a filter lasts years. The second is freezing, and this one is silent. Water left in the fibres expands as it freezes and cracks them, and a cracked filter looks and flows exactly like a good one while passing everything through. Once a filter has been used, assume it will fail if it ever drops below 0 C. On cold nights it sleeps in the sleeping bag with us, in a zip bag. If it has frozen, or we are not sure, it is retired.
Chemicals: what they treat and how long they take
Chlorine dioxide, sold as tablets or as two-part drops, is the chemical we trust. Unlike iodine, it kills Cryptosporidium, it works across a wide pH range, and it leaves little taste. The contact times matter and they are longer than most people wait. For bacteria and viruses, 15 minutes in clear water at 20 C. For Giardia, 30 minutes. For Cryptosporidium, a full four hours. In cold or cloudy water, double the shorter times. Tablets weigh nothing and do not freeze, so we always carry a strip of ten as a backup even when the filter is the main method.
Iodine is cheaper and works on bacteria and Giardia in 30 minutes, but it does not touch Cryptosporidium, it tastes of iodine, and it should not be used for more than a few weeks or by anyone pregnant or with a thyroid condition. Household bleach at two drops per litre for 30 minutes is a last resort with the same gaps.
UV and boiling
UV pens scramble the DNA of everything in a litre of water in about 90 seconds, and they kill viruses, which filters miss. They need clear water, because UV cannot reach a cell hiding behind a speck of silt, and they need batteries, which suffer in the cold. We consider UV a fine second stage after a filter where viruses are plausible, and a poor sole method on silty rivers.
Boiling is the oldest and most complete method. A rolling boil kills everything; above 2,000 metres a full minute at the boil is sensible because water boils cooler up high. The cost is fuel: about 10 grams of gas per litre from cold, which adds up fast for a group.
How much to carry
The body needs roughly 0.5 litres per hour of steady hiking in mild conditions of 15 to 20 C, and that rises quickly. At 25 to 30 C on open ground, plan on 0.75 to 1 litre per hour. In desert heat above 32 C, 1 litre per hour is the minimum and 1.5 is not unusual on a climb. Below 5 C the need falls to about 0.3 to 0.4 litres per hour, but thirst falls further, and dehydration in winter is common because nobody feels like drinking. A simple check is colour: pale yellow is right, dark yellow means drink now.
What you carry is set by the sources, not the day. Before a trip we mark every reliable water source on the map and estimate the hours between them, then carry enough for the longest gap plus a 20 percent margin. A typical planning table for a moderate day looks like this:
- Sources every 1 to 2 hours, cool weather: carry 1 litre, drink at each source
- Sources every 3 to 4 hours, warm weather: carry 2 to 3 litres
- Dry camp with no evening source: add 2 litres for cooking and the morning
- Desert with sources 6 or more hours apart: carry 5 to 6 litres and start before dawn
Camel up at each source, drinking half a litre on the spot rather than carrying it. Streams marked on maps often run dry by August, so check recent trip reports and treat any source you cannot confirm as absent.
Camp habits that keep you well
Most stomach trouble on the trail is not from the water at all. It is from hands. Wash or sanitise before every meal and after every toilet stop, keep the dirty and clean bottles clearly separate, never let the outlet of a filter touch untreated water, and collect from moving water upstream of the trail and of any camp. Treating the water and then eating with dirty hands is the most common mistake we see, and the cheapest to fix.
